{ "status": "accepted-by-agent", "at": "2026-09-15T12:28:12.420351+00:00", "ownerApproval": false, "score": null, "candidate": { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v05/gopure-targ-uk-master.wav", "sha256": "fe51c03ca73ebac441a8021089e6df7295210808c1a5ce533f834dc51f153975" }, "unresolvedBlocking": [], "decision": "Accept articulation02 A, with conservative opening trim/constant gain and a locally substituted truly sung B final invitation, as the checked second musical version beside preserved version1. Sharper completed pickup, independent facts/questions and audible rhythmic spaces meet this experiment direction. Do not claim every release or transition is superior, or assign an owner score.", "limitations": [ "Model-mediated listening, not continuous human listening or owner approval. Entire separate files were supplied; actual input coverage does not prove uniform model attention.", "Four high-bitrate stereo body audits cover the complete source/candidate with overlap. Full-form review receives all four full recordings at48kmono; final blind ending and care receive192kstereo.", "Word times are ASR estimates with explicit uncertain/interpolated spans, not phoneme measurements. Performed musical groups are larger heard periods;60individual phrase observations separately describe their attacks/releases.", "Second слід, first-reveal ні and pre-ingredient крем retain broader vowel shaping than the sharper ideal; the English source remains more effortlessly conversational. Some newly created spaces can feel deliberate.", "Advice-to-handoff contains a short vocalise within its roughly4.1s word-to-word gap. Ingredient gaps expose rhythm; independent melodic guitar replies are not reliably established.", "The practical coda remains denser than English and quieter than the narrative peak. Complete sung words and all conditions are checked, but the new result is not an unreserved aesthetic10/10.", "Both musical tasks are known SUCCESS. The first experiment and local pronoun comp were rejected. critical-blind-v01 has provider-error-outcome-unresolved and was never repeated; malformed returned reviews are preserved but excluded from acceptance.", "Same fictional cosmetic neck story;3/6-week complete result is not a universal efficacy guarantee. Same cast/problem images reused byte-for-byte; future film must recheck actual complete visual resolution, continuity and fades. No new film.", "Final sung entrance has an audible delivery/room change; review finds no click or chord dissonance. Two-/three-syllable imperative readings conflict; mix/stem and unchanged contextual evidence support залиш ім’я, with coarticulation disclosed.", "A final line and the first rate-mismatched local export were rejected; v05 uses exact48000Hz A prefix and sung B tail. Final handoff clock is216.362979s, not an old film duration." ], "validAuditoryRuns": [ "repaired-ending-v02", "final-form-v03", "ending-mode-v01", "opening-v02", "care-blind-v03", "master-body1-v02", "master-body2-v02", "master-body3-v02", "master-body4-v02", "final-form-v02", "ending-blind-v02" ], "masterAuditoryRuns": [ "repaired-ending-v02", "final-form-v03", "care-blind-v03", "master-body1-v02", "master-body2-v02", "master-body3-v02", "master-body4-v02", "final-form-v02", "ending-blind-v02" ], "wordReviewNames": [ "repaired-ending-v02", "master-body1-v02", "master-body2-v02", "master-body3-v02", "master-body4-v02", "care-blind-v03", "ending-blind-v02" ], "coverageDisclosure": "All194.376s English audio (container194.488934s),197.726s owner7–8baseline,203.240998s preserved version1 and216.362979s exact new WAV received as separate complete48kmono files in final-form-v03. Four corresponding128kstereo source/preserved/new blocks cover each entire track with0.6s boundary overlap;192kstereo blind care/ending supplement words. No retiming; actual constant gains in derivation receipts. Fragments are not described as continuous human listening.", "wholeFlowAssessment": "The same nine narrative blocks remain in order. Completed pickup and independent peer name break the prior rhyme tail; two questioning contours retain real melody. Recurring слід resolves into rhythmic space; sharper double gaze remains audible. Elapsed-weeks and recital entrances reset activity. Personal judgment resolves before the lower-register coda. Local care and final instructions remain intelligible. Longer216.363s does not itself prove quality; widened releases and the advice vocalise are explicit remaining tradeoffs.", "remainingSourceGap": "Targ still has more unforced conversational timing, short everyday-word releases and compact product/coda density. The experiment succeeds at specified word/action changes without reproducing every source gesture.", "adjudications": [ { "claim": "The preserved first-pity clause is grammatically wrong or lacked a correct pronoun.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Preserved version1 had an evidenced corrected мене and remains unchanged. The new nominal pity clause avoids the first experiment stress dispute; it is a lexical choice, not proof that old grammar was wrong.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/takes-screen-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1a98625d6ff99a1e85a6f8857c8742fa255fdfb9581b7854a6ca5adec2a110b3" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body1-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "e575ca8d4a790bb04117026d1a8790994793422fc7f94a4aa1629887b38206b6" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-adjudication-v01.json", "sha256": "1a8019ff217ca0a0b51754833474a99d87db4f4f2fc71b0d8edd66b8709064a3" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "New care says indicative міняю or ingredient Купу is missing its ending.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "ASR segmented the sung command/name badly. Blind exact-master review identifies final-й imperative; body3 hears Не міняй крем and complete Купуасу́. Blind review distinguishes middle pitch peaks from final lexical stress but lists an alternative; contextual high-bitrate review hears held final су. This is an agent adjudication with retained phonetic uncertainty, not forced alignment.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/care-blind-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6fc21098eafdbe5be72984f8ca0561f1dcb400b566da9b3e726f888a22bedaaf" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body3-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "022005314d9148bc802183cd171ef2107a4117e1fcee50a0663422fb9666d5aa" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/takes/take_articulation02_1.asr.json", "sha256": "a20ddfb0e0f5e70565e07299ef3d7b42f4da27aed89141f7584a620e345d7e8e" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/stress-ledger-v02.json", "sha256": "754a0f6657a9b3e279f497a0f26d9505e038b4aa8449d143a3685b38a4745403" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Excerpt head/tail truncation means the master cuts off кришку or its ending.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Care clip107..130raw-equivalent intentionally ends inside following application context. Full body3 has Кришку зняла and following complete result. Actual master continues to216.363s; local transport boundary is not a master cut.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/care-blind-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6fc21098eafdbe5be72984f8ca0561f1dcb400b566da9b3e726f888a22bedaaf" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body3-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "022005314d9148bc802183cd171ef2107a4117e1fcee50a0663422fb9666d5aa" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body4-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "256d66d9ee746990bd4c99bf7bbff202ff066d4522f88a53a69533a98826f699" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Care reviewer measured frequency spectra/waveforms and WAV has fewer source compression artifacts than its raw MP3.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "No such measurement was supplied. WAV is a decode of that MP3 with constant gain and opening trim; it cannot undo codec loss. Model instrument/phoneme labels are auditory estimates only.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/care-blind-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6fc21098eafdbe5be72984f8ca0561f1dcb400b566da9b3e726f888a22bedaaf" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v05/provenance.json", "sha256": "6af181eebd96a2f718701778716031a9df0336f9c37f00f126051b72d07657bd" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "The source is spoken voiceover; its coda or Stop is literal silence.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Complete source and established canonical/gap reviews support speech-shaped singing; both codas sing. Holds and decay are not empty signal. No music edit was made to fix this invented categorization.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/care-blind-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6fc21098eafdbe5be72984f8ca0561f1dcb400b566da9b3e726f888a22bedaaf" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "48f916562d44e6a2e71ab37b362c31e1be0b0d99a14c29fe44a275da1715af47" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-music-gap-b614aa3b3e-20260915/owner-feedback-v01.json", "sha256": "ddb3fce06e5fc60cf2d0596b73b6c94430b2cdc5700f38f8589e6ddb2ff6a358" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Every source/target rhythm is identical or perfectly synchronized; source facts or phoneme times can be copied from reviewer text.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Reviewers repeatedly use unsupported perfect/precise labels and occasionally substitute wrong source endings (Next issue, June came), nonword release syllables, and times for access words. Keep actual attached coverage and observed gestures; discard exact note/phoneme/timing assertions. Source canonical transcript and performed ASR locate the words.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body1-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "e575ca8d4a790bb04117026d1a8790994793422fc7f94a4aa1629887b38206b6" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body2-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "3325767c975bee31499c3f1df98fd84aeb669562b20121f553afbad3c46ae440" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body3-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "022005314d9148bc802183cd171ef2107a4117e1fcee50a0663422fb9666d5aa" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body4-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "256d66d9ee746990bd4c99bf7bbff202ff066d4522f88a53a69533a98826f699" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-refined-ce99390b3b-v01/song/source-rhetoric-v02.json", "sha256": "9c787a22c85017b2cc295544c8eb952499145a4c6baa927b0be58adf0ecd9e9e" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "There is a distinct melodic guitar reply after every ingredient.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Whole screen hears guitar/bass replies, blind care hears continuous groove, body3 hears percussive hits. Common supported observation: separated complete names and exposed rhythm. Do not claim a standalone melodic lick is proven.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/takes-screen-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1a98625d6ff99a1e85a6f8857c8742fa255fdfb9581b7854a6ca5adec2a110b3" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/care-blind-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6fc21098eafdbe5be72984f8ca0561f1dcb400b566da9b3e726f888a22bedaaf" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body3-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "022005314d9148bc802183cd171ef2107a4117e1fcee50a0663422fb9666d5aa" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "The expanded216.363s length itself requires a200–205s master, and every vowel hold violates the brief.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Owner explicitly permits new section lengths and selective word/melody play, while prohibiting constant rushing and routine smearing. A fixed old duration or uniform staccato would contradict this. Assess where a hold helps or remains a disclosed gap.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "48f916562d44e6a2e71ab37b362c31e1be0b0d99a14c29fe44a275da1715af47" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/owner-feedback-v01.json", "sha256": "7c87f9fd618951ec69a6daf3536f3afef81ae353aa5df7e84b4db9b4b13f627e" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/articulation-plan-v02.json", "sha256": "7707cbf417318392e0408f6970c3c61b50ddc2c00f92bbc284a5f529d3e0de3c" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "All new holds match the written intention.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Second слід, reveal ні and pre-ingredient крем are broader than planned; accept those specific experimental deviations with a disclosed source gap. They do not erase the clearer pickup/questions and breathing evidence. No global perfect-art pass is inferred from filled fields.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "48f916562d44e6a2e71ab37b362c31e1be0b0d99a14c29fe44a275da1715af47" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/takes-screen-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1a98625d6ff99a1e85a6f8857c8742fa255fdfb9581b7854a6ca5adec2a110b3" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/care-blind-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6fc21098eafdbe5be72984f8ca0561f1dcb400b566da9b3e726f888a22bedaaf" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "A cream hold delays entry into Наступного дня.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Whole reviewer misorders events: pre-ingredient крем is p34 AFTER the handoffp31. Actual advice-to-handoff gap has a brief vocalise and rhythm; do not edit later cream as a repair for earlier transition.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "48f916562d44e6a2e71ab37b362c31e1be0b0d99a14c29fe44a275da1715af47" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/takes-screen-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "1a98625d6ff99a1e85a6f8857c8742fa255fdfb9581b7854a6ca5adec2a110b3" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body3-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "022005314d9148bc802183cd171ef2107a4117e1fcee50a0663422fb9666d5aa" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/diagnostics-v02/alignment-articulation02-take1-draft-v01.json", "sha256": "7fc36c39c870ab6a7fad88ffdc1b52185c40de985b9e11eded3a510d985c40ce" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Pre-repair A last invitation was spoken despite the generic body4 sung label.", "disposition": "accepted-observation", "reason": "Two independent focused reviews of mix/diagnostic vocal classify A last invitation as speech. A is not accepted unchanged. Version05 preserves exactA PCM through209.4s, then substitutes B actually sung last invitation and tail; new local seam and complete-form reviews arbitrate the result.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/ending-blind-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6d9c4bba42e2b98df34f5d59af69c0f53816c064044f0ad78553de3267ba287c" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/ending-mode-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "8ccef16406f7ccac5cbb4477551652c8202c6de0fed5658bd18f5cf80ca63436" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repaired-ending-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "d95659fffdc6d0319c854e8cc10cbb3e06c7ee6bbdbfe2d788bd51e48949d40b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "81b3c63f6d3b1a090a77a206be85688a01cd8f082b39b7a7da947267858a0f23" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v05/provenance.json", "sha256": "6af181eebd96a2f718701778716031a9df0336f9c37f00f126051b72d07657bd" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "New version gains the specific owner-requested pickup, question play and musical space.", "disposition": "accepted-observation", "reason": "All whole/local comparisons identify completed забрала, separated Лариса, interrogative Що за догляд / А ти що наносиш and exposed accompaniment between short facts/causes. Full sequence, explicit donor, neck payoff and all coda conditions remain heard.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "48f916562d44e6a2e71ab37b362c31e1be0b0d99a14c29fe44a275da1715af47" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body1-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "e575ca8d4a790bb04117026d1a8790994793422fc7f94a4aa1629887b38206b6" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body2-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "3325767c975bee31499c3f1df98fd84aeb669562b20121f553afbad3c46ae440" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body3-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "022005314d9148bc802183cd171ef2107a4117e1fcee50a0663422fb9666d5aa" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body4-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "256d66d9ee746990bd4c99bf7bbff202ff066d4522f88a53a69533a98826f699" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Every generated export used44.1kHz and the first ending comp was valid.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "New raw takes and v03 WAV are48000Hz. First local compv04 mistakenly reinterpreted sample positions at44100Hz and was rejected by duration inspection BEFORE review. Version05 probes both formats, preserves48000Hz and verifies exactPCM prefix and expected duration. Old v03 provenance rate label is wrong but its audio clock was correct. Diagnostic Demucs stem received48k rather than model44.1k, so it has additional separation uncertainty and is never used in the master.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repaired-ending-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "d95659fffdc6d0319c854e8cc10cbb3e06c7ee6bbdbfe2d788bd51e48949d40b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/director-edit-v03.json", "sha256": "f6ef89cc06eeb4e8815dec69deb154788120cfab282e0de59378b732fcd1ec19" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v05/provenance.json", "sha256": "6af181eebd96a2f718701778716031a9df0336f9c37f00f126051b72d07657bd" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Final master retains a known spoken last line.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "Actual revised ending and whole form are reviewed after the B substitution; decision relies on that exact new audio and unchanged-prefix proof, not the earlier generic body4 pass.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repaired-ending-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "d95659fffdc6d0319c854e8cc10cbb3e06c7ee6bbdbfe2d788bd51e48949d40b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "81b3c63f6d3b1a090a77a206be85688a01cd8f082b39b7a7da947267858a0f23" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v05/provenance.json", "sha256": "6af181eebd96a2f718701778716031a9df0336f9c37f00f126051b72d07657bd" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "A blind ending review proves additional syllable in Залиши or omits name.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "The diagnostic A mix/stem comparison hears two-syllable залиш; body4 and complete ordering context hear ім’я й номер. Blind ending-v02 reconstructed an extra verb vowel; ending-mode-v01 then incorrectly claimed name absent despite the earlier contextual and later corrected-ending evidence. Preserve these contradictions rather than treating its transcription as exact.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/ending-blind-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "6d9c4bba42e2b98df34f5d59af69c0f53816c064044f0ad78553de3267ba287c" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/ending-mode-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "8ccef16406f7ccac5cbb4477551652c8202c6de0fed5658bd18f5cf80ca63436" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body4-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "256d66d9ee746990bd4c99bf7bbff202ff066d4522f88a53a69533a98826f699" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repaired-ending-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "d95659fffdc6d0319c854e8cc10cbb3e06c7ee6bbdbfe2d788bd51e48949d40b" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Repaired ending verbatim proves І справді так відчувала, extra imperatives, three-second decay, or the order coda starts at209.4s.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "The exact prefix through209.4s is unchanged; ASR/body4 establish Я щиро / Так і відчуваю and brand already at197s. Local review borrowed words from previous comparator. Diagnostic mix/stem hears two-syllable залиш before ім’я; contextual body4 confirms name/number. Preserve competing readings as coarticulation uncertainty, not invented missing name. Actual final B word edge approximately214.99s and decoded end216.362979s do not support three seconds of tail. Source order remains canonical, not reviewer rearrangement.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repaired-ending-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "d95659fffdc6d0319c854e8cc10cbb3e06c7ee6bbdbfe2d788bd51e48949d40b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/ending-mode-v01/evaluation.json", "sha256": "8ccef16406f7ccac5cbb4477551652c8202c6de0fed5658bd18f5cf80ca63436" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/master-body4-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "256d66d9ee746990bd4c99bf7bbff202ff066d4522f88a53a69533a98826f699" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "81b3c63f6d3b1a090a77a206be85688a01cd8f082b39b7a7da947267858a0f23" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v05/provenance.json", "sha256": "6af181eebd96a2f718701778716031a9df0336f9c37f00f126051b72d07657bd" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/takes/take_articulation02_1.asr.json", "sha256": "a20ddfb0e0f5e70565e07299ef3d7b42f4da27aed89141f7584a620e345d7e8e" } ], "blocking": false }, { "claim": "Repaired final entrance is acoustically identical to unedited A.", "disposition": "rejected-observation", "reason": "New local and whole reviews hear the change toward sung delivery; local reviewer reports room/processing shift but no click or chord dissonance. Return word ends~207.31s, more than2s before crossfade209.4s, so the claim that its vocal itself is abruptly cut is not supported. Accept the audible stylistic turn as a disclosed local repair, not an invisible edit.", "evidence": [ { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/repaired-ending-v02/evaluation.json", "sha256": "d95659fffdc6d0319c854e8cc10cbb3e06c7ee6bbdbfe2d788bd51e48949d40b" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/reviews/final-form-v03/evaluation.json", "sha256": "81b3c63f6d3b1a090a77a206be85688a01cd8f082b39b7a7da947267858a0f23" }, { "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/ce99390b3b/runs/targ-articulation-ce99390b3b-v01/song/master-candidates/v05/provenance.json", "sha256": "6af181eebd96a2f718701778716031a9df0336f9c37f00f126051b72d07657bd" } ], "blocking": false } ], "phraseDispositions": { "p01": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p02": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p03": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p04": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p05": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p06": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p07": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p08": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p09": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p10": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p11": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Second слід has a wider melodic turn than planned. Accepted as an audible second-cause variation with a distinct release/response, while retaining this as a gap to Targ short cadence." }, "p12": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p13": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p14": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p15": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p16": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p17": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p18": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Ні is more pitched/extended than dry intention. Accepted because the heard negation→worse→pity steps remain separate; not evidence that all delivery must be clipped." }, "p19": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Першою uses a longer thought-closing vowel; accepted for the inner comparison, not imposed on routine actions." }, "p20": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Сиджу holds its final vowel; whole reviewer hears some drag, local reviewer hears syncopated car reaction. Accepted as a specific sustained emotional state; no strict prior duration target." }, "p21": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p22": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p23": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p24": { "disposition": "realized", "observationOverrides": { "heardVowelAndRelease": "Completed забрала moves onward; танців ends the clause. Reviewer literal hard ц description is not adopted as a phoneme transcription." } }, "p25": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p26": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p27": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p28": { "disposition": "realized", "observationOverrides": { "heardVowelAndRelease": "Question turns melodically and releases наносиш. The reviewer typo шиш is not an extra sung syllable." } }, "p29": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p30": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Advice resolves into a short vocalise/groove bridge before next-day handoff, rather than wholly instrumental reply. Clear Стій and changed action survive; remaining source gap disclosed." }, "p31": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p32": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p33": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p34": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Крем is held more broadly than desired. Imperative now remains clear; retain this audible tradeoff instead of claiming a dry short release or buying a whole new song merely to force a uniform rule." }, "p35": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Names are complete and separated; exact autonomous guitar replies are disputed. Accept exposed rhythm/percussive spaces and final-stress Купуасу, with wider name hold and uncertainty disclosed.", "observationOverrides": { "heardVowelAndRelease": "Complete Купуасу́ final-su hold; Гіалуро́н and Живлення і волога separated. Final word волога is not claimed to end with an h phoneme." } }, "p36": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p37": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p38": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p39": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p40": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p41": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p42": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p43": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p44": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p45": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p46": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p47": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p48": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p49": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p50": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p51": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p52": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p53": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p54": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p55": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p56": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p57": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p58": { "disposition": "realized" }, "p59": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "Ordering information is locally denser than narrative and English coda; all conditions remain sung rather than removed for a shorter clock." }, "p60": { "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "reason": "A last line was conversational and failed sung gate. Same-run B supplies the complete actually sung invitation and decay through a240ms instrumental crossfade. Entire earlier A performance remains unchanged.", "extraReviewNames": [ "repaired-ending-v02", "final-form-v03" ], "observationOverrides": { "heardAttack": "Complete new invitation entry after rhythm pocket, from same-run B.", "heardVowelAndRelease": "Sung five-word invitation with connected pitch and final vowel release; actual revised ending review supersedes pre-repair A description.", "densityObservation": "One complete five-word phrase; no words added or rushed to fill former clock." } } }, "musicalGroupOverrides": { "master-body4-v02": [ { "plannedPhraseIds": [ "p47", "p48" ], "semanticFocus": "Public recital setting", "contourRhythm": "Steady narrative 4/4 adaptation", "release": "Clean stop on 'класу' and 'піаніно'", "holdBreathOrResponse": "Brief instrumental answer between phrases", "arrangement": "Piano-driven support", "boundaryCue": "Shift from intimate home tone to public event", "planDeviation": "None" }, { "plannedPhraseIds": [ "p49", "p50" ], "semanticFocus": "Confrontation with the gaze", "contourRhythm": "Fragmented, hesitant meter", "release": "Sharp on 'Розгублена'", "holdBreathOrResponse": "Pause for emotional impact after 'співчуття'", "arrangement": "Stripped back accompaniment", "boundaryCue": "Cadence on 'Розгублена'", "planDeviation": "None" }, { "plannedPhraseIds": [ "p51", "p52" ], "semanticFocus": "Compliment and causal memory", "contourRhythm": "Rising on compliment, falling on 'авто'", "release": "Clipped on 'авто'", "holdBreathOrResponse": "Instrumental bridge before 'Дякую'", "arrangement": "Fuller texture returns", "boundaryCue": "Memory resolution", "planDeviation": "None" }, { "plannedPhraseIds": [ "p53", "p54", "p55" ], "semanticFocus": "Internalized self-worth", "contourRhythm": "Lyrical, expansive", "release": "Held 'ціную' with selective vibrato", "holdBreathOrResponse": "Extended musical resolution (breath8)", "arrangement": "Gently fading accompaniment", "boundaryCue": "Personal arc completion", "planDeviation": "None" }, { "plannedPhraseIds": [ "p56", "p57", "p58", "p59" ], "semanticFocus": "Product and ordering conditions", "contourRhythm": "Balanced speech-sung coda", "release": "Повернення releases before instrumental pocket", "holdBreathOrResponse": "Actual A ordering block unchanged up to209.4s", "arrangement": "Minimalist, steady pulse", "boundaryCue": "Final song exit", "planDeviation": "Final invitation now separately grouped from repaired B." }, { "plannedPhraseIds": [ "p60" ], "semanticFocus": "Optional final personal invitation", "contourRhythm": "Pitched final invitation from B; listen to exact revised export.", "release": "Complete final внизу and retained B musical decay.", "holdBreathOrResponse": "Instrumental pocket precedes complete sung line.", "arrangement": "Existing same-run B coda accompaniment enters via240ms crossfade before voice.", "boundaryCue": "Actual final sung phrase after ordering conditions", "planDeviation": "Local donor correction replaces spoken A last line without retiming.", "reviewNames": [ "repaired-ending-v02", "final-form-v03" ] } ] }, "sectionObservations": { "s1": "Complete immediate hook; independent age and pity facts, short March/aside articulations.", "s2": "Three accumulating слід cells with accompaniment space; second is more melismatic. Discrete store objects then gaze.", "s3": "Negation, worsening and pity are separate; car reflection expands on concrete neck problem before a rhythmic hinge.", "s4": "Completed забрала, isolated Лариса, age/neck contrast, pitched question and counter-question; list changes into sung Стій.", "s5": "Named donor gives purple jar. Imperative clear; cream hold broader. Ingredients separated by rhythm pockets, then lid/finger/upward neck action.", "s6": "Three-week observation and daughter quote build toward held six, complete smooth-neck result and exposed-neck behavior.", "s7": "June recital resets; second gaze separates negations/confusion. Compliment and car callback retain the causal memory.", "s8": "Thanks and her/own contrast resolve inward with a purposeful ціную hold; both older versions already carried this meaning.", "s9": "New sung brand entrance; complete ordering conditions; quieter optional invitation and full decay." }, "transitionFindings": { "tr1": { "heardResponse": "Bass/guitar groove establishes the first слід cell after старша.", "comparisonToIntention": "Distinct change from comparative backstory to accumulating causes.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body1-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "tr2": { "heardResponse": "Smile releases into isolated negations and pity reveal over ensemble decay.", "comparisonToIntention": "Different rhetorical attacks; no assertion of literal zero signal.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body1-v02", "master-body2-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "tr3": { "heardResponse": "Falling згасло gives way to rhythmic pickup for Того тижня.", "comparisonToIntention": "New practical scene starts clearly after inner reflection.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body2-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "tr4": { "heardResponse": "After щодня, short vocalise over groove precedes Наступного дня.", "comparisonToIntention": "A separated hinge exists but is partly vocal, not the intended exclusively instrumental answer. Accepted as short scene transition; source remains more immediate.", "reviewNames": [ "takes-screen-v02", "master-body2-v02", "master-body3-v02" ], "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "adjudicationReason": "A separated hinge exists but is partly vocal, not the intended exclusively instrumental answer. Accepted as short scene transition; source remains more immediate." }, "tr5": { "heardResponse": "Комфортно releases; accompaniment leads into Три тижні.", "comparisonToIntention": "Elapsed-time step audible after care, without deleting application actions.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body3-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "tr6": { "heardResponse": "Шиєю resolves before the rhythmic entry Червень.", "comparisonToIntention": "Public return is a different entry after product-specific behavioral payoff.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body3-v02", "master-body4-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "tr7": { "heardResponse": "Авто callback releases; accompaniment clears for Я щиро / Дякую.", "comparisonToIntention": "Transition leaves space for internal response, while connected scene clauses remain connected.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body4-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "tr8": { "heardResponse": "Ціную resolves with accompaniment; fresh lower-register Ґоу П’юр entrance.", "comparisonToIntention": "Coda follows personal resolution as a separate sung referral; no invented obligatory silence length.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body4-v02", "final-form-v02", "ending-blind-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" } }, "spaceFindings": { "breath1": { "heardResponse": "First слід releases into bass/guitar rhythm before Нічні сльози.", "comparisonToIntention": "Instrumental pocket separates accumulating causes.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body1-v02", "takes-screen-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "breath2": { "heardResponse": "Broader second слід ends, then groove carries the lead into Дітям.", "comparisonToIntention": "Recognizable answer remains, though preceding vowel is longer than intended.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body1-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "adjudicationReason": "Recognizable answer remains, though preceding vowel is longer than intended." }, "breath3": { "heardResponse": "Жалість lands over ensemble decay before the longer На́че comparison.", "comparisonToIntention": "A rhetorical release is heard, not necessarily a stand-alone silent gap.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body2-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "breath4": { "heardResponse": "Танців closes and Лариса receives an independent entry within continuing groove.", "comparisonToIntention": "Short scene clauses breathe; no routine забирала/зустрічала rhyme tail.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body2-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "breath5": { "heardResponse": "After щодня, short vocalise over groove precedes Наступного дня.", "comparisonToIntention": "A separated hinge exists but is partly vocal, not the intended exclusively instrumental answer. Accepted as short scene transition; source remains more immediate.", "reviewNames": [ "takes-screen-v02", "master-body2-v02", "master-body3-v02" ], "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "adjudicationReason": "A separated hinge exists but is partly vocal, not the intended exclusively instrumental answer. Accepted as short scene transition; source remains more immediate." }, "breath6": { "heardResponse": "Комфортно releases; accompaniment leads into Три тижні.", "comparisonToIntention": "Elapsed-time step audible after care, without deleting application actions.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body3-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "breath7": { "heardResponse": "Шість sustains pitched sound and disbelief resolves into the full neck result.", "comparisonToIntention": "Hold/release is meaningful sound, not two seconds of empty silence.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body3-v02", "final-form-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "breath8": { "heardResponse": "Ціную resolves with accompaniment; fresh lower-register Ґоу П’юр entrance.", "comparisonToIntention": "Coda follows personal resolution as a separate sung referral; no invented obligatory silence length.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body4-v02", "final-form-v02", "ending-blind-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "breath9": { "heardResponse": "Повернення ends; accompaniment is exposed before final Якщо invitation.", "comparisonToIntention": "Purchase condition and optional closing thought receive separate spaces.", "reviewNames": [ "master-body4-v02", "repaired-ending-v02" ], "disposition": "realized" }, "breath10": { "heardResponse": "Held крем closes before separated Купуасу; bass/rhythm continues.", "comparisonToIntention": "Imperative/name separation achieved; cream vowel wider than intended, no proven solo guitar reply.", "reviewNames": [ "care-blind-v03", "master-body3-v02" ], "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "adjudicationReason": "Imperative/name separation achieved; cream vowel wider than intended, no proven solo guitar reply." }, "breath11": { "heardResponse": "After Живлення і волога, a longer rhythm pocket precedes Оливні ліпіди.", "comparisonToIntention": "Exposed accompaniment replaces continuous ingredient run; exact melodic response attribution disputed.", "reviewNames": [ "care-blind-v03", "master-body3-v02" ], "disposition": "deviation-accepted", "adjudicationReason": "Exposed accompaniment replaces continuous ingredient run; exact melodic response attribution disputed." } }, "cellNotes": { "cost-cell": "Three causes return to слід; second varies with extra vowel motion, third expands caregiving. Instrumental spaces preserve accumulation.", "gaze-cell": "Не злість/ще гірше/жалість returns as Не жалість/не співчуття/розгублена; repetition changes interpretation.", "opinion-cell": "Anger at own mirror state returns as her judgment versus own worth; both sides explicitly sung.", "recognition-return": "Store encounter returns at recital, compliment recalls car, then self-worth precedes optional product referral." }, "causalityNotes": { "care-cost": "Oksana supports children while distressed; multiple causes accumulate in visible exhaustion. No literal holding-children ambiguity.", "glance-wound": "Nataliia looks at Oksana neck; pity triggers car/mirror reaction and explicitly named neck dryness/bands/creases.", "advice-reset": "Larysa asks what she applies, hears constant changes and interrupts with Стій/daily care. No claim all prior methods medically damaged her neck.", "jar-transfer": "Наступного дня Лариса дала мені банку names donor, action, recipient and object.", "application-result": "Lid/finger/upward neck care precedes three-week partial result, held six/full smooth neck and going out with neck exposed; face foundation does not substitute for neck resolution.", "return-selfworth": "Nataliia returns gaze/compliment, Oksana sincerely thanks; own assessment matters after actual neck result was already sung." }, "heardRests": [ { "time": [ 24.63, 26.65 ], "observation": "Word-locator interval after first слід and before Нічні; accompaniment remains audible. Approximate response pocket, not measured silence.", "method": "Word locator minus1.15s plus full/local auditory evidence.", "uncertainty": { "seconds": 0.3 } }, { "time": [ 94.27, 98.39 ], "observation": "Advice-to-handoff bridge includes short vocalise and continuing groove. It is not an empty instrumental-only gap.", "method": "ASR edge context plus fullscreen/whole auditory adjudication.", "uncertainty": { "seconds": 0.4 } }, { "time": [ 207.31, 210.67 ], "observation": "Return condition releases into exposed accompaniment before final invitation.", "method": "Word locator and body4/blind ending.", "uncertainty": { "seconds": 0.3 } }, { "time": [ 214.99, 216.362979 ], "observation": "Complete final внизу releases into remaining musical decay.", "method": "ASR approximate final word edge and actual full ending review; decoded WAV duration.", "uncertainty": { "seconds": 0.25 } } ] }